Marriage Proposal on the girl's birthday - yes or no?

legally blond wrote:

If you two end up divorced for some reasons, then she will associate her birthday with something perhaps that ends of negative. Pick another day.

You are a sad human being.

The guy is looking for relationship advice on Letsrun. I would suggest that the chances of this ending well are close to zero. He will be alone and sad, he might as well get used to it.

Propose another day.....for her birthday, maybe bake her a cake or something.

Divorce is for quitters.

Congrats for coming to the least likely place to get proposal advice. What you should do is tell her that if she can run 10 miles on her birthday you'll at least think about the possibility of marrying her - some day.

Actually, what's wrong with doing it (I mean proposing) on her birthday?

legally blond wrote:

If you two end up divorced for some reasons, then she will associate her birthday with something perhaps that ends of negative. Pick another day.

This chick is RETARDED....

Sorry i got here late, has anyone suggested a solution involving POWERPOINT?

legally blond wrote:

If you two end up divorced for some reasons, then she will associate her birthday with something perhaps that ends of negative. Pick another day.

-----------------

If nothing else, this is the perfect reason to propose on her birthday. If she ever leaves you, her birthdays will always have a bitterness to them that can't be soothed with alimony.

i bet she is hot

Don't do it on her birthday. That's just lame - it's one of the few days of the year that is supposed to be about her and her alone. This makes it about both of you. Instead, do something crazy and original, like get your cock pierced - with the engagement ring as the piece. Then propose to her when she's about to go down on you. She'll unzip your pants and see the ring and it'll be awesome. Then, after she says yes, you can get a b.j.!

Whatever you do, don't hide it in some food...most of the time, the ring will just get eaten and you'll have to sift through her shit to find it. If you like that sort of thing, it's cool but if not, you better just stick to the cock piercing.

No need to thank me for the advice. I and the rest of this board would, however, appreciate updates. Especially on whether you gave her a facial.

I think the birthday proposal has some advantage in that it will save you the cost of a present in addition to the Curbic Zirconium ring she is lucky to receive. Another person already pointed out that the probable divorce is another good reason to use her birthday for the engagement day, the bitter divorce will cause terrible memories of the marriage and consequently ruin her b-day. You will have the last laugh. You may also want to use another cost-cutting ploy by getting married on X-mas day. This will allow the combination of anniversary/x-mas gifts on an annual basis. My final piece of advice is to make sure she doesn't mind threesomes because 2 women are always better than one.

most of this advice is so bad...but I can't stop laughing at it...hahahaha

Definitely a good idea. Proposing on a day that is already special to your partner is a great way to coordinate a marriage proposal. If you are interested in proposal ideas here are some unique ideas http://www.themarriageproposal.com/

ProposalPro wrote:

Definitely a good idea. Proposing on a day that is already special to your partner is a great way to coordinate a marriage proposal. If you are interested in proposal ideas here are some unique ideas

http://www.themarriageproposal.com/

Thanks for the advice, but if OP was going to propose, he probably would have done it some time in the 13 years since he started this thread.

I would say no.

My wife really loves celebrating her birthday, I would not want to cloud that with anything else.

Is OP update? Did you go with the pierced cock move?

Don't do it. It's lazy and a cop out. Pick another day to be a special day that the two of you can look back on.