PUBLISHED ANALYSIS SHOWS MUTAI'S BOSTON TIME NOT EXCESSIVELY AIDED
By David Monti
April 22, 2011
(c) 2011 Race Results Weekly, all rights reserved
(22-Apr) - Geoffrey Mutai's time at last Monday's Boston Marathon was indeed fast, but according to an analysis released today by the
independent Association of Road Racing Statisticians (ARRS) his mark
should not be viewed as excessively aided.
Writing in this week's "Analytical Distance Runner," the official ARRS
publication, chief analyst Ken Young wrote: "It should also be noted
that Geoffrey Mutai (KEN) who ran 2:03:02 (in Boston), was ranked #2 on
the ARRS competitive rankings and he had been ranked #1 for four weeks
earlier in the year. When Haile Gebrselassie (ETH) set the current
world record of 2:03:58.2, he was ranked #10 in the world. Hence, it is
not surprising that Mutai could be capable of significantly bettering
the world record. Too bad that he ran this on a course that is not
eligible for records."
According to the Young's Race Time Bias (RTB) calculation, a measure of
how fast athletes run based on their previous performances over all
distances, the times at Boston were 1:37 fast for the men and 1:42
seconds fast for the women. That worked out to 2.29 seconds per
kilometer for the men and 2.41 seconds per kilometer for the women.
Both figures are well within the 5 seconds per kilometer value the ARRS
uses to disqualify performances as excessively aided.
"The net drop is worth about 3 sec/km," Young continued. "The observed
times were roughly 2.4 sec/km faster than expected for the 43 elite
runners making up the time comparisons. Hence, one could conclude that
the wind aid was sufficient to balance out the effect of the hills (such
as they are)."
Young also pointed out that there were years at Boston where athletes
ran much faster per kilometer than this year, based on what would be
expected. The fastest year for men was 1981 when times were fast by 3.8
seconds per kilometer (2:40 total), and 1988 and 1991 for the women,
where times were 4.2 seconds per kilometer (2:57 total) fast.
Interestingly, Young points out that the RTB for Boston over all years
for which the ARRS has kept data averages out to +0.3 seconds per
kilometer, essentially the same as a flat course. That would seem to
indicate that over a long span of time the effects of the weather have
canceled out (favorable and unfavorable), and the up and down nature of
the course generally produces honest times, even if the course falls by
3.23 meters per kilometer, more than three times the amount allowed for
setting world records.
The male and female athletes who ran the fastest based on what was
expected were Ecuador's Franklin Tenorio, whose 2:17:56 was 8:51 fast,
and Colombia's Yolanda Caballero, whose 2:26:17 was 11:01 fast.
"These RTB values for Boston are well within the range for statistically
valid performances and marks from this race are included in the ARRS
rankings," Young concluded.
|
|
|
Runner's World &
Running Times
Combined Only $22
a Year
Save $87
Running & Track and Field Posters
Great Offer: Nike Lunar Glide Sale Multiple colors of this shoe available.
*Nike Air Max Moto 7 Get 2 Pairs for a Crazy $112