Sand Dunes wrote:
http://pennshape.upenn.edu/files/pennshape/Body-Composition-Fact-Sheet.pdf
Hi banana nut. This lists things that could happen, not things that will happen, and at less than 8% bodyfat, not 10%, so way to be wrong twice in one post.
Sand Dunes wrote:
http://pennshape.upenn.edu/files/pennshape/Body-Composition-Fact-Sheet.pdf
Hi banana nut. This lists things that could happen, not things that will happen, and at less than 8% bodyfat, not 10%, so way to be wrong twice in one post.
You're confusing 2 entirely different things: Weightlifting & Diet
Weightlifting controls your strength. Diet controls your weight.
@sandy wrote:
Sand Dunes wrote:
http://pennshape.upenn.edu/files/pennshape/Body-Composition-Fact-Sheet.pdfHi banana nut. This lists things that could happen, not things that will happen, and at less than 8% bodyfat, not 10%, so way to be wrong twice in one post.
Smoking could give you lung cancer, but it might not happen.
8% vs 10%, wow at least he was in the ball park.
Stope the madness!!!!
Why would you make a post asking a question about if you weight too much or not and then tell anybody who says you are that they're wrong and you're a good weight
I can relate. I was a middle distance guy (800&1500) I was 6' and 174 lbs with 2.7% body fat (bod pod tested, not calipers). My coach told me the EXACT same thing. So If you want to be the best runner you can then stop lifting!!! if your built like you say you are then you don't need to be in the weight room.
jacked too wrote:
I can relate. I was a middle distance guy (800&1500) I was 6' and 174 lbs with 2.7% body fat (bod pod tested, not calipers). My coach told me the EXACT same thing. So If you want to be the best runner you can then stop lifting!!! if your built like you say you are then you don't need to be in the weight room.
Absolutely BS.
BS detector going off the charts wrote:
jacked too wrote:
I can relate. I was a middle distance guy (800&1500) I was 6' and 174 lbs with 2.7% body fat (bod pod tested, not calipers). My coach told me the EXACT same thing. So If you want to be the best runner you can then stop lifting!!! if your built like you say you are then you don't need to be in the weight room.
Absolutely BS.
Thats what the machine told me 14 years ago anyways. I had a body composition test done 3 years ago. same thing, in a bod pod (the one that displaces air not water FWIW) I was still 6" and 185lbs, that time I was 7.5% body fat. May have had a tiny bit more muscle than college but most of that weight was just putting on a healthy layer of fat.
BROFESSOR wrote:
@sandy wrote:
Hi banana nut. This lists things that could happen, not things that will happen, and at less than 8% bodyfat, not 10%, so way to be wrong twice in one post.
Smoking could give you lung cancer, but it might not happen.
8% vs 10%, wow at least he was in the ball park.
It says "The attempt to reduce body fat by extreme measures not only leads to decreased exercise performance,
but it also can lead to severe health complications."
Nothing about being
Nothing about being < 10% body fat is itself unhealthy. But you can't expect an imbecile like Sand Dunes/Banana Nut/Gravy to be able to read and comprehend anything correctly.
EasternWash wrote:
BS detector going off the charts wrote:
Absolutely BS.
Thats what the machine told me 14 years ago anyways. I had a body composition test done 3 years ago. same thing, in a bod pod (the one that displaces air not water FWIW) I was still 6" and 185lbs, that time I was 7.5% body fat. May have had a tiny bit more muscle than college but most of that weight was just putting on a healthy layer of fat.
Same machine? If so it needs to be calibrated. Or you just did the test wrong. There are things that can mess up the test.
Alan
Runningart2004 wrote:
EasternWash wrote:
Thats what the machine told me 14 years ago anyways. I had a body composition test done 3 years ago. same thing, in a bod pod (the one that displaces air not water FWIW) I was still 6" and 185lbs, that time I was 7.5% body fat. May have had a tiny bit more muscle than college but most of that weight was just putting on a healthy layer of fat.
Same machine? If so it needs to be calibrated. Or you just did the test wrong. There are things that can mess up the test.
Alan
I'm assuming they were different machines. The test were done 11 years apart and thousands of miles from each other, but you never know I guess. and ya maybe I did the test wrong, I didn't think it was very hard to sit in there in your underwear with a shower cap on and not move but maybe I screwed that up. Or ya maybe the professionals trained to operate each of their respective machines didn't have them calibrated correctly.
Sorry, I just need you to point out where I told someone they're wrong and that I'm a good weight. Thanks!
I wish I had the body of a guy hoe instead of a long-distance runner...
My lame two cents wrote:
Probably not what u want to hear, but it yea, you’re too big. If you’re running the 400 or 800 you’re okay, but not for distance. What’s with the weightlifting insistence anyway? You’re either a distance runner or a lifter
FWIW, I was 5’8” and 120 lbs when I ran. That’s 1.76 lbs per inch. You’re at 2.32
Weight does not scale linearly with height. I'm unsure of the exact relationship, but taller people also are wider in general.
Abel Mutai one of the thicker Kenyans.
I've really thankful for all the feedback I've gotten on this thread. Just so you all know, even though I may not 100 % agree with my coach, I am following his weight plan. And I've decided to lose around 5 pounds and no more, at least for cross country season. I'll keep you guys updated on my seasons, and if and when I post again I'll post under the same username. Once again, thanks so much guys! This was my first post and I really enjoyed engaging with you guys! Hope y'all run some fast times and keep on keeping on, Godspeed!
Way too much volume. Run, then lift afterwards. A lifting session might be as simple as this:
Squat 3x250lbs
Bench 3x145lbs
Don't worry about doing a ton of low intensity exercises. You want heavy weight, low volume. You are really just "topping-up" your running stimulus. Expend all your effort during your runs. Top up the stimulus after. There's minimal value in doing pyramids of 55 pullups and 110 pushups.
Posters telling you to challenge your coach's authority are 100% wrong! Most NFL players lift weights. Daunte Culpepper, former 6'4" 265 lbs. NFL QB with 4.5 NFL Combine 40 yard dash speed was told to not lift weights by NFL coaches. Culpepper gained weight too easily. Posters have gotten stuck in the weeds challenging your body fat percentage. You're a bit heavier than Jim Ryun. Run, do plyometrics and enjoy the extra time you have since you do not have to lift weights like the others.
What do the following all have in common: Herb Elliott, Seb Coe, Mo Farah, Taoufik Makhloufi and Gordon Pirie?
Jakob Ingebrigtsen has a 1989 Ferrari 348 GTB and he's just put in paperwork to upgrade it
Strava thinks the London Marathon times improved 12 minutes last year thanks to supershoes
Is there a rule against attaching a helium balloon to yourself while running a road race?
NAU women have no excuse - they should win it all at 2024 NCAA XC
Mark Coogan says that if you could only do 3 workouts as a 1500m runner you should do these
2024 College Track & Field Open Coaching Positions Discussion
Clayton Murphy is giving some great insight into his training.