Big Game James (Shields) of the KC Royals and formerly of the TB Rays - a guy who had a few good post-season games in 2008 and since then has been a post-season disaster.
OR
Matt Ice (Ryan) of the Atlanta Falcons - earned his nickname while performing well as a rookie IN THE REGULAR SEASON and has under-performed in almost every post-season game in which he has played.
How do these guys keep these names? Which one should be forced to give his back first?