This bit from the week in review had me thinking:http://www.letsrun.com/news/2014/05/week-review-payton-jordan-5000m/
I'd say point 1 misses the point. Since only 6 American men have broken 13 ever, it's obviously not how it "often works." While only 2 of the 6 (Lagat and Rupp) will be likely running 5000s this year, we have 6-10 other guys who are potentially capable of breaking 13 this year. That's unprecedented, but it doesn't mean a bunch of them won't, just because it's never happened before. I think we'll see several sub-13s this summer, and it'll be awesome.
Point 2 is just wrong. Speed work is not overrated. While solid times can be achieved early in the season, I don't think anyone has won a medal or run world leading times without speed work. Speed work is essential to winning a championship race, and just because those championship times are not fast doesn't mean that they are not in shape to run much faster.
I think the problem is that the Diamond League races have enough prize money that pro athletes are more concerned about winning the money than fast times, just as in championships. Put a bunch of world-leading athletes in a race like Stanford Invite around August, with cash incentives rewarded by time not place, I'm sure we'd see a record-breaking number of men running sub-12:50.
As it is, there's enough races in Europe that the opportunity should arise for a good evenly paced race. As long as enough American men get the opportunity to race enough in Europe, I'd predict about five Americans breaking 13:00, and both Rupp and Lagat likely breaking the American Record.
So how fast do you need to be to medal? It's easy enough to figure that out. Here's all the medalists since 2007:
PR, Year, All-time place, WC & Olympic Medals since 2007
12:37 '04 (1) Kenenisa Bekele - G '08, G '09
12:46 '04 (9) Eliud Kipchoge - S '07, S '08
12:46 '12 (10) Dejene Gebremeskel - B '11, S '12
12:47 '12 (12) Hagos Gebrhiwet - S '13
12:48 '12 (15) Isiah Koech - B '13
12:49 '12 (20) Thomas Longosiwa - S '11, B '12
12:50 '07 (34) Moses Kipsiro - B '07
12:51 '13 (40) Edwin Cheruiyot Soi - B '08
12:53 '11 (64) Mo Farah - G '12, G '13
12:53 '11 (73) Bernard Lagat - G '07, S '09, G '11, 4th '12
12:54 '03 (93) James Kwalia - B '09
Times range between world-record holder Bekele and Kwalia's 12:54, with an average of about 12:48. Looks about right. Both Farah and Lagat never really ran for times, and were easily in at very least 12:48 shape when they won their medals.
U.S. Top 12
1 12:53.60 '11 (73) Bernard Lagat - G '07, S '09, G '11, 4th '12
2 12:55.53 '10 (124) Chris Solinsky - 12th '09
3 12:56.27 '09 (154) Dathan Ritzenhein
4 12:58.21 '96 (215) Bob Kennedy
5 12:58.56 '09 (228) Matt Tegenkamp - 4th '07, 13th '08, 8th '09
6 12:58.90 '12 (249) Galen Rupp - 9th '11, 7th '12, 6th '13
7 13:01.15 '85 (395) Sydney Maree
8 13:02.40 '13 (479) Evan Jager
9 13:02.74 '14 (505) Ben True
10 13:02.80 '14 (510) Hassan Mead
11 13:07.95 '14 Lopez Lomong - 10th '12
12 13:08.04 '13 Chris Derrick
U.S. men have a long way to go, but I think we've got at least 3 guys who could get in sub-12:50 shape by 2014 and 2015.
While we're at it, here's the women:
PR, Year, All-time place, WC & Olympic Medals since 2007
14:11 '08 (1) Tirunesh Dibaba - G '08, B '12
14:12 '08 (2) Meseret Defar - G '07, B '08, B '09, G '11, G '12, G '13
14:20 '11 (4) Vivian Cheruiyot - S '07, G '09, S '12
14:24 '04 (10) Elvan Abeylegesse - S '08
14:25 '13 (13) Almaz Ayana - B '13
14:31 '10 (42) Sylvia Kibet - S '09, B '11
14:35 '11 (77) Mercy Cherono - S '11, S '13
14:35 '06 (80) Priscah Cherono - B '07
The average is about 14:24. Mercy Cherono certainly seems capable of that. The bad news for American women is they are much further off pace. To have any chance at all to medal, they probably need to get in at least sub-14:35 shape. The best bet right now is Huddle of course, and maybe if Simpson moved back up to 5000.
U.S. Top 12
1 14:44.76 '10 (231) Molly Huddle - 11th '12, 6th '13
2 14:44.80 '07 (232) Shalane Flanagan - 8th '07, 10th '08
3 14:45.35 '00 (246) Regina Jacobs
4 14:51.62 '00 (421) Deena Kastor
5 14:54.29 '08 (504) Jennifer Rhines - 7th '07, 14th '08, 9th '09
6 14:55.02 '07 (533) Kara Goucher - 9th '08
7 14:55.74 '10 (568) Lisa Uhl
8 14:56.04 '96 (581) Amy Rudolph
9 14:56.07 '93 (585) Annette Peters
10 14:56.26 '13 (596) Jennifer Simpson
11 14:56.72 '10 Amy Yoder-Begley
12 14:58.48 '08 Lauren Fleshman - 7th '11
Good news is we've got some very promising young talent coming up, but it's hard to say that anyone will be at 14:35 level within two years.