Fantasy Football - Give me your opinion

Team B for me by quite a lot. I have my draft on Sunday and if I landed that roster (16 team league), I think I would win it hands down.

Which one is yours?

fantasy dude wrote:

Team B for me by quite a lot. I have my draft on Sunday and if I landed that roster (16 team league), I think I would win it hands down.

Which one is yours?

I quite agree:

I'm gonna say C,B,D,A,E,F although B may be the best. All the teams have their strengths and weaknesses though.

B is definitely strong. The only thing is, Schaub is a Tier 3 QB, and Donald Driver is a pretty weak WR2.

In a twelve team league, though, all teams have weaknesses.

I like team A: Very strong at every position except WR. Excellent RB1 and RB2, top level QB/TE/K/DEF.... but def. weak receivers. I guess you gotta accept some weakness in a league with that many teams.

C ain't bad either. E is awful. Horrible receivers and not enough star power to make up for it.

So c'mon man, which one is yours?

Where's Steve Slatton and LT, plus where is Calvin Johnson. This league is bogus

Team D is by far the best. It has 3 Seahawks.

aaaaa wrote:

Where's Steve Slatton and LT, plus where is Calvin Johnson. This league is bogus

Dude... relax. I didn't give you all twelve teams. I thought that would be a bit of overkill. I gave you the six teams I thought were strongest.

LTs team looks like this:

Team G

QB: Tony Romo DAL

RB: LT SD

RB: Marshawn Lynch BUF (Ray Rice RB#3 while Lynch is out)

WR: Andre Johnson HOU

WR: Brandon Marshall DEN

TE: Zack Miller OAK

K: Garrett Hartley NO

DEF: JETS

CJ's team looks like this:

Team H

QB: McNAbb PHI

RB: K. Smith DET

RB: D. Ward TB

WR: C. Johnson DET

WR: G. Jennings GB

TE: G. Olsen CHI'

K: N. Kaeding SD

DEF: Tennessee

I didn't think these teams were strong enough to list originally...

Slaton's team....

Team I

QB: Carson Palmer CIN

RB: S. Slaton HOU

RB: DeAngelo Williams CAR

WR: Roddy White ATL

WR: Wes Welker NE

TE: Dustin KEller NYJ

K: D. Akers PHI

DEF: Giants

See... not quite as strong as the original 6 IMO..

So, now that you have that info, which team do you like?

By the way, many of you are mentioning team B (it's not mine) - that guy had the #1 pick. Good team.

Team F aint so bad.. cept that it has 3 falcons on it. too many eggs in one basket, but the other teams have issues too.

id say F-B-C

My opinion is that Fairy Tale Football is not for men.

Team B is definitely the best. Donald Driver is underrated and Schaub would have put up much bigger numbers last year if he wasn't injured.

I'm not wild about the WRs - Cotchery is all dependant upon a rookie QB performing well (and, by well I mean 18-20 TDs), while Moss is so streaky he's difficult to rely upon as a fulltime starter. In my 14 team league he's my 4th WR. The rest of the team is very solid - here's hoping Warner doesn't have a down year, tho.

I'm not a Portis fan - similarly to Moss, he's streaky and injury prone. Smith scares me b/c I'm not sold on Delhomme remaining productive. I'm picking nit, tho, as this is a solid team.

I like this team a lot, despite the presence of Westbrook. Assuming there's an adequate b/u RB, this team will perform well. I think it's the best team - Brady alone could propel this team in the stratosphere.

Hasselbeck will make or break this team - if his O-line can protect him I think he'll have a bounce-back, 25+ TD year. If not... could get real ugly. Obviously, as Hass goes so goes Housh. Second tier team, tho.

I want to like this team but there's just too many question marks with Avery, Shockey and, to a lesser extent, Bryant and Jacobs. STL offense is horrible even with Bulger healthy, Shockey underwhelms, can Bryant produce two years in a row, and can Jacobs stay healthy?

As someone else mentioned, 3 ATL players could really doom this team. ATL plays a much more difficult schedule this year and Turner's stats were night and day depending on the strength of the defense he faced last year. Ryan's top end is maybe 25 TDs. I'm not sold on Ronnie Brown, either.

My feeling is C has the biggest upside, followed by B.

God bless ya, Eugene. C is my team. Westbrook was a tough pick - sitting in the 8th spot, I was kind of stuck. I've got LeSean McCoy as a handcuff, so here's hoping I'll be ok.

Team B (the dude who picked #1) is solid, def. Tean A (he had pick #2), is really nice as well. We agree pretty much.

You just provided me with a lil' smack support - I'll share your analysis, for sure.

If Brady gets hurt again? Well.. I guess I'm screwed.

here's my 14-team league roster (drafted in 3rd position) - obviously, I like your team b/c it's similar to mine:

QB: Schaub

RB: Forte

RB: White

WR: Calvin J

WR: V Jax

TE: Shiancoe

K: Bironas

D: Buffalo

b/u:

qb: Leftwich

rb: D Ward, E Graham

wr: E Royal, S Moss, S Smith (NYG), J Morgan, P Garcon

te: none

k: none

D: none

I had to grab the best of not a lot available w/ D, didn't pick 'em until round 16. I was shocked Calvin dropped to me in 2nd round and got another gift w/ White in the 6th round. I picked Ward in the 5th round, Graham in the 8th - I think Ward will perhaps be my starter in place of White but I'm waiting to see how it shakes out b/w him, Graham and Cadillac. If I have to start Leftwich for any extended time I may be in deep trouble. I really wanted Flacco but he was grabbed as someone's 3rd QB just before me. I think he'll have a 20+ TD year.

Team A is the best. Team B follows closely behind. I'm surprised more people haven't jumped on team A's bandwagon.

Big Man wrote:

Team A is the best. Team B follows closely behind. I'm surprised more people haven't jumped on team A's bandwagon.

Warner is old and could drop off (of course he could have another great season). Marion Barber is overrated and will have a lot of his touches taken by Felix Jones and Taschard Choice. I still don't get all of the MJD hype either. Santana Moss will be inconsistant and probably won't get a ton of TD's (This is coming from a Skins fan). Cotchery will have a rookie QB throwing to him so he is a bit of a wildcard as well.

Morning Zoo w/Dick Gobbler wrote:

My opinion is that Fairy Tale Football is not for men.

Bump. Fantasy football is for friggin' losers. Just root for your favorite team and forget the fantasy crap.

Get a freaking life.

Team H, B, F, C... in no particular order. I believe clinton portis isn't very injury prone as he runs the ball 40 times a game just about. That's not injury prone, just a stupid coach.

Man, that's a solid team for a league that big. You got nice depth at RB, and especially WR.. something I wish I had more of. We had sort of the same strategy: draft a solid RB#1, then build a series of later round RB2 options - sort of a "by committee" thing. (Mine go Westbrook and then White/L. McClain/Leon Washington - plus I have L. McCoy in case Westbrook gets dinged up). I think it frees you up to get a top tier QB and WR, then top level TE, while others go RB-RB with their 1st two picks and then play catch up. Just a different approach.

I spent my 5th pick on Clark (TE), but I had to sacrifice by waiting to pick up my WR2. I need more depth there (I've got Colston, V. Jackson, L. Moore, Earl Bennett, & Percy Harvin). Nice job snagging C. Johnson. He went at the very beginning of round two in our draft (13th overall, 3rd receiver). You've got really nice depth at that position.

Nice call on Flacco. I think he went undrafted for us. I may end up dropping my TE#2 and grab him...

Anyway, good luck dude.