Pages: | 1 | 2 |
b runs
Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 12:28AM Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
If you had to pick either LeBron James or Ashton Eaton to play on your team in a sport that was neither's specialty, so not T&F and no Basketball (or Football for good measure), for which sports would you take each athletic specimen?

Soccer: Eaton. He has better endurance although James might be able to play a mean sweeper (is that a real position or just something my high school coach said?)
Baseball: James
Hockey: James
Gymnastics: Eaton
Tennis: Eaton
Golf: Eaton
Wrestling: Freestyle Eaton Greco James
Trollist
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 12:32AM - in reply to b runs Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
If both of those guys have any skill, a tennis match between them would be one helluva competition.
thirty-two
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 1:25AM - in reply to b runs Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Why so sure on baseball? James's strike zone is massive, and you gotta think Eaton's getting around those bases pretty damn quick. Guess it comes down position. Same with hockey, James would be an easy hit at 6'8" and Eaton's probably quicker on skates as well.

The REAL question is...is Eaton better at basketball than LeBron is at decathlon??
asdfadsfads
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 1:34AM - in reply to thirty-two Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
probably. he's the greatest athlete of all time.
themanontherun
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 7:09AM - in reply to b runs Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Specificity trumps size, almost every time.

Eaton has practiced so many different specific movements, and gotten very efficient at all of them. LeBron has practiced many different specific movements as well, but centered around one game.

I might give LeBron an edge in something where pure size really does make a huge difference, like wrestling, or certain specific positions in football, and probably powerlifting as well. Beyond that, I can't think of too many sports where he would out-perform Eaton.
53 milion a year
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 8:52AM - in reply to themanontherun Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

themanontherun wrote:

I can't think of too many sports where he would out-perform Eaton.



Lebron's bank deposit skills are a little better than Eatons.
asdfasdf
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 8:57AM - in reply to themanontherun Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

themanontherun wrote:
I might give LeBron an edge in something where pure size really does make a huge difference, like wrestling, or certain specific positions in football, and probably powerlifting as well. Beyond that, I can't think of too many sports where he would out-perform Eaton.


LeBron was the state player of the year in football in high school. If he were to declare for the NFL draft, he'd be a first round pick for sure even at his age. He's tall and strong, he can jump, and he can catch - he'd be unguardable as a receiver or tight end. Even if he's got a high center of gravity and isn't as elusive as most WRs he's got 50 pounds on a lot of NFL cornerbacks.

I'd take Eaton in most free flowing field sports though for the combination of elite quickness and solid endurance.
thirty-two
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 10:45AM - in reply to asdfasdf Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

asdfasdf wrote:
LeBron was the state player of the year in football in high school. If he were to declare for the NFL draft, he'd be a first round pick for sure even at his age. He's tall and strong, he can jump, and he can catch - he'd be unguardable as a receiver or tight end. Even if he's got a high center of gravity and isn't as elusive as most WRs he's got 50 pounds on a lot of NFL cornerbacks.



You have no clue what you're talking about, if any high schooler declared for the NFL draft they would go undrafted or very late at best.
present tense
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 10:49AM - in reply to thirty-two Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

thirty-two wrote:

You have no clue what you're talking about, if any high schooler declared for the NFL draft they would go undrafted or very late at best.


James isn't a high schooler.
Lebron could own Eaton
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:03AM - in reply to b runs Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Lebron's personal assistant, maid, butler, and driver probably all make more than Eaton. Eaton got a $750k bonus for setting a WR while Nike gave Lebron a $100million contract while he was still in high school. Who cares who the better athlete is, Lebron could literally own Eaton if he so wanted. End of discussion.
My guess
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:04AM - in reply to thirty-two Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

thirty-two wrote:



The REAL question is...is Eaton better at basketball than LeBron is at decathlon??


Not only is Eaton better at basketball than LeBron is at decathlon, but with a few months of training he would be better at basketball than LeBron is at basketball. I mean, Eaton is a real athlete in a real sport, not some candy-@ss pot smoker in the NBA who gets by on size alone.
Thats a clown comment BRO
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:16AM - in reply to My guess Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

thirty-two wrote:

Not only is Eaton better at basketball than LeBron is at decathlon, but with a few months of training he would be better at basketball than LeBron is at basketball. I mean, Eaton is a real athlete in a real sport, not some candy-@ss pot smoker in the NBA who gets by on size alone.


^^ Yeah because Lebron smokes pot and runs over top of people / dunks on everyone 100% of the time. Not. I love track as much as the next guy on lets run but you sir have no idea what you are talking about.
????????
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:43AM - in reply to Lebron could own Eaton Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
You can't own a person. Not literally. Also not what the question is...

He didn't ask who's life is better. Although from listening to both of their interviews I would rather be Eaton. Makes enough to live comfortably, not nearly the pressure or attention from media, able to live his life without a bunch of sycophants sponges following him around. Seems smart, probably makes better eh..decisions.
Lebron could own Eaton
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:50AM - in reply to ???????? Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
That's where your wrong. Ths is America. If you have enough money you can own whatever you want to and Lebron has enough money to own Eaton if he wanted to.
LBJ
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:56AM - in reply to Lebron could own Eaton Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
LeBron plays nearly 48 min a game in the NBA, I'm sure he has pretty good endurance. I'd take LeBron is most sports over Eaton. And this isn't a baskeball superiority thing, Eaton would kill the next best guy in the NBA, but LeBron is a once in a generation freak.
Junk Master
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 11:57AM - in reply to Lebron could own Eaton Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
RG III is a much better bet to beat Lebron in any sport.
????????
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 12:47PM - in reply to LBJ Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
You can only own a person who wants to be owned. He could have Eaton killed I guess or threaten his family, but you can't just buy a person. Lebron could only own me if he did some shady as shit.
Lebron could own Eaton
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 2:58PM - in reply to ???????? Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
You're confusing how it should be with how it really is, because it is not the want of the owned that matters but rather the want of the owner. Nobody wants to be owned, but in this great country if you have enough money you can do whatever you want to and own whatever and whoever you want to. I'm not saying that Lebron is at the top of the food chain just higher than Eaton. Guys like Bill Gates could own Lebron if he wanted to and Micky Arison does own him.
my pickeros
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 4:00PM - in reply to b runs Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Soccer: Eaton

Baseball: Eaton

Hockey: Eaton

Gymnastics: Eaton

Tennis: Eaton but don't know

Golf: don't care

Wrestling: Freestyle Eaton Greco James. He would have a huge size advantage

Boxing: Tough one. I'd go with James but the later rounds go with Eaton

Volleyball - indoor James outdoor Eaton

Football - James

MMA - James

Beer Pong - James

Table Tennis - don't know

Diving - Eaton

Swimming - Eaton

Mud Run - Eaton
every college wanted him thoug
RE: Lebron James vs. Ashton Eaton in neither's event 6/27/2012 7:22PM - in reply to asdfasdf Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

asdfasdf wrote:


LeBron was the state player of the year in football in high school. .


Lebron made first team all-ohio but he was never the state player of the year.
Pages: | 1 | 2 |